Mark Sandlin,
Part 3 of my sabbatical adventure away from the church entitled: "Church No More."

A little over a month ago I (an ordained minster who has gone to church my whole
life) walked away from church– for three months. It is what I've decided to do
with my sabbatical. You can read about my initial thoughts on my blog or on The Huffington Post. As the journey unfolds, I will be blogging about it in this series entitled, “Church No More.” I hope you will not only follow along, but add your voice to the reflection by commenting or joining the discussion on my FB page.





I have a confession. (That's rich, right? A minister confessing.) I have a hard time telling people I'm a minister. Yes, really. I actually tend to handle it this way -- Person: “So, what do you do for a living?” Me: “I'm a minister... (appropriate pause), but not the kind you just pictured in your head.”

Sad. I know. Honestly though, it's worse than that. I'm even very resistant to calling myself a “Christian.” And I'm not even close to the only Christian who feels that way! It's so bad that I have this very conversation with people all the time. There seems to be some kind of “Believer-like-me Radar” which tells people it's safe to talk to me about not liking the“C” word –Christianity.

You'd be amazed at how many people resist calling themselves Christian –or maybe you wouldn't. Maybe you are one of us. The “C” word just isn't what it used to be. 

A number of researchers over the last few years (most notably David Kinnaman and Gabe Lyons who published their results in unChristian) have found that the word “Christianity” has many more negative connotations than positive ones, at least in the minds of the general public. Want to try a few of them on for size? Hypocritical. Irrelevant. Antihomosexual. Judgmental. Okay, that's enough. I'm getting depressed.

I've been on sabbatical from ministry for a little over a month now. I decided from the very beginning that during the three months I'm on sabbatical, I will not go to church. I've never done that for more than a couple of Sundays in my whole life. Ever. And it worried me.

I'm finding that not only did I not need to be worried, but I don't actually miss church much.

Don't get me wrong, I really miss the people (the actual church) but I simply don't miss what Church has become. I don't miss the dogma. I don't miss the hypocrisy. I don't miss the judgment. I don't miss all of the stuff that Jesus didn't like about orginized religion during his day and age. Go figure.

I'm left with this thought: “How am I supposed to follow Jesus when the place I'm told I'm supposed to do it invests so much energy in the stuff that Jesus didn't like about orginized religion during his day and age?” Isn't that counterproductive? It's no wonder that so many people are walking away from church, never looking back and, in doing so, finding happier lives. The “C” word just isn't what it used to be.

Church has become about following the Church and all of those who hold power in it (both formal and informal power). Silly me, I thought we were supposed to be following Jesus. The reality is, when the rest of the world can rightfully look at us and calls us hypocritical, judgmental and irrelevant, and say that we are much more defined by what we are against rather than what we are for -- well, we are not doing a very good job of following Jesus. We are not being very good Christians.

My time away from the Church has helped me see more clearly that the Church is increasingly full of Churchians rather than Christians. We've become so tied up in the power structures and dogma of the organization that we've lost focus on the “Christ” in Christian. We put polity before people and trade love for law. We follow the Church not Christ.

If you stop and think about it, with all of that in mind, it makes a lot sense that people are leaving the churches to find their spirituality. What I still need to ponder on this journey is, can the Church change? What would that look like? Would it make any difference at this point? How can we honor and respct those who have left the Church (for many valid reasons) and be in ministry with them?

Can we make the “C” word mean what it used to mean? I sure hope so.

The journey continues.
 
 
 


Comments

Sue King
07/11/2012 14:04

Your comments hit the nail on the head and are why I stopped going to church years ago. I have, from time to time, tried attending different churches, even those with more socially liberal approaches, but came away still feeling disconnected from the dogma being preached, however softly. I have, as I've gotten older, wondered how can I honor my spiritual committment, which is important to me, be truthful to my conscience while still believing in God, but not the church. I've spent time reading Buddhist teachings and there is much there that informs and moves me deeply -- but I'm not a Buddhist -- I do not wish to, as the Dalai Lama put it, "put a yak's head on a sheep's body." So I find myself going back to something that began when I was very young, 12 years old, of sitting in church, having read that Sunday's Bible chapter, listening to the elders expound on it only to think, "but what does it mean really -- what is under this?" Strip away the dogma and start with compassion, understanding, mercy and forgiveness - make that the practice (there are days, far too many of them when doing all that is hard work -- but I AM working on it) and go from there. I hope what I've written makes sense. Take care!

Reply
Vicki
07/11/2012 14:38

we love the one right in front of us. As Ann Lamott writes, "we try to do the next right thing." as a pastor, though, you also have a responsibility to preach it from the pulpit. No one "in" church likes or even believes the gospel message. It should melt them in their pews with its radical, non-PC power. Preach it. You'll get fired, but hallelujah. There isno security outside ofChrist. We must take back both C words - church and Christianity.

Reply
07/11/2012 14:39

I am not Christian. I am Jewish, but have, over the last year or two, had the same experience as you. I have always been very dedicated to my spirituality. I spent 10 years meditating with Maharishi and teaching TM (I still meditate) but my Judaism has always also been a very important and central part of my identity. At one time, and for 10 years, I wanted to become a rabbi and did become a para-rabbi and taught religious school, ran programs, services, etc. for many years. Allergies are my excuse for no longer going to services although I still pray daily. I don't even go on holidays. Too much perfume? Yes, but also too much breast beating and too little joy--way, way too little joy. And what there is feels manufactured, not real.

Thank you for your integrity and honesty in making your feelings public. It must be hard. I have not had the courage to be that honest consistantly. I'm really glad I happened on this post via Facebook and Huff Post. Blessings to you in your journey!

Reply
Me
07/11/2012 15:40

I have not "officially" left the church because the only person i know who is not christian is my husband. to everyone around me, anything but "Churchian" Christian is horrible and you are going to hell. I had the same effect as you. when i left, i started to find a deep spiritual connection with God and how i did that was by experimenting with different religions and mashing the stuff that worked for me together. to bring people back to God you need to bring people back to Earth! take nature walks as a community and share communion in nature. don't just repeat meaningless prayers, make your own and share them. share your spiritual experiences rather than feeling it's shameful or people will think you're crazy for having those experiences. Listen to the teachings of the religions of the world, maybe they know something we don't know. do yoga! it's like praying with your body, while offering your heart and soul to God. instead of just saying a quick prayer for them, make them something that will have a longer lasting effect. this is how God brought me back to God.

Reply
Gerald
07/11/2012 15:40

I have a pastor who gives us information from The Bible and lets us use it in our life. It is mostly the other people who attend telling us how to believe and what to believe.

Reply
Forrest Shelton Clark
07/11/2012 16:06

Mark,

I am in full agreement with you. I am retired clergy (I retired two years ago after 44 years of ordained ministry). For the first three months after I retired, I took a sabbatical from the church. In those three months, I went to church once (just because it felt right that week and resulted in meeting a delightful clergywoman who has once served in the same state I did). I have returned to "church" attending worship services regularly, not because I missed the institution, but because I missed the people. I thought I'd found a church with some contemporary consciousness but soon discovered that it was merely a cloak for luring people in and then trying to persuade them of the old dogma and the old sociological connections. I attend another congregation now but only because the lead pastor is a good friend of mine. I have not been able to find a progressive assembly of people who want to walk with Jesus on a daily basis and not be tied up in the machinations of the institution. Thank you for what you are writing. Please know there are certainly some of us out here that are where you are whether we are in active or retired ministry.

Reply
07/11/2012 16:41

to figure whwere I belong. Sad isn't it.

Reply
07/11/2012 18:47

I would venture to say that there are a large number of Muslims, Jews, Catholics and other individuals that are experiencing the same conflict of conscious. One needs to search no farther that Jesus’ example when he threw the “money changers out of the temple”. Organized religion is all about the number of people that it claims control over not the guidance it provides to the individual seekers of Gods guidance. It’s more about being attractive than being helpful.

Reply
Mark Pragnell
07/11/2012 19:09

The problem of having a 'personel relationship'' with god is that it is indistinguishable from mental neurosis. How does one differentiate "normal" religious or spiritual experiences from psychotic symptoms To quote Sigmund Freud In Future of an Illusion, Freud (1927) wrote:

"Religion would thus be the universal obsessional neurosis of humanity... If this view is right, it is to be supposed that a turning-away from religion is bound to occur with the fatal inevitability of a process of growth…If, on the one hand, religion brings with it obsessional restrictions, exactly as an individual obsessional neurosis does, on the other hand, it comprises a system of wishful illusions together with a disavowal of reality, such as we find in an isolated form nowhere else but amentia, in a state of blissful hallucinatory confusion…"

There are also several studies that show a prevalence of religious delusions in patients with schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and other severe mental disorders. While about one-third of psychoses have religious delusions, not all religious experiences are psychotic.

As for christians who follow Jesus's teachings for example ''Turn the other cheek'' (Mathew 5-38/40) and ''take no thought for tomorrow''(Mathew 6-34) I ask you ''Would you invite someone who stole from you to do so again?'' and ''Don't consider your childrens future or pay into a pension. Savings? get rid of them, planing a holiday ? no, no, no''.
Who would hold these teaching up high? None but a fool!

Reply
Lance Anderson
07/22/2012 02:56

I don't think William James, the father of Psychology, who wrote extensively on the subject of religion, including a book called The Varieties of Religious Experience, or psychiatrist Carl Jung, who some regard as the father of Spiritual Psychology, and whose work led to the development of Transpersonal Psychology, would agree with Sigmund Freud's assessment.
The work of Dr. Raymond Moody, Dr. Melvin Morse, and Dr. Kenneth Ring in regards to Near Death Experiences and Mystical States show a positive, transformative effect on individuals who have those experiences.
There is also the work Neuroscientist Andrew Newberg. In the early 1990s, he began to research the intersection between the brain and religious and spiritual experiences. His work is sometimes referred to as “neurotheology”, This work was eventually published in three books, The Mystical Mind, Why God Won’t Go Away, and Why We Believe What We Believe. He has continued to study religious and spiritual phenomena including topics related to forgiveness, meditation, prayer, spiritual development, morality, and belief. This work has been incorporated more recently into a new Center for Spirituality and the Mind at the University of Pennsylvania. His work work shows a positive correlation between prayer, contemplative practices, meditation and good mental health.
As for the teachings of Jesus, you did not "have ears to hear". The teaching of "turning the other cheek", is intended to show a way in which to shame an offending party instead returning violence for violence. Such methods were used with great success by Gandhi and Marting Luther King, Jr. As for the teaching "take no thought for tomorrow", Jesus is simply trying to get us to focus on living today because today is all we really have. Practically all spirtiual traditions teach that. Evern Alcoholics Anonymous has the slogan to "live one day at a time". In the NIV Bible, Matthew 6:34 actually says "Therefore, do not worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will worry about itself. Each day has enough trouble of its own". In summation of Matthew 6:25-34, Jesus says have faith in God, seek His Kingdom and He will meet your needs, so don't be filled with anxiety and worry about the future. It does not say we should not use our common sense and plan appropriately for the future. There is a big difference between planning for the future and living in the future or living with anxiety and worry about the future.

Reply
Phylis Neill
07/11/2012 20:12

I always tell people that I'm a disgruntled Jesus freak & recovering lesbian! LOL!... :P Many years ago a friend gave me a book , "The Subtle Power Of Spiritual Abuse" by Johnson & VanVonderan... I would not still be a believer if God had not put this book into my hands... Churches often house broods of vipers... they poison your relationship w/God... I often find myself struggling NOT to lose my 1st love... As a homeless, divoriced single mom it was hard to feel a sense of God's love, mercy & forgiveness in church... I don't think religous people have much tolerance for anyone that doesn't "measure up" and they despise and reject the poor & needy on a social level... Love is much more than giving someone a basket of food... and Jesus was a homely, homeless man... He identifies personnally w/ the poor & needy and takes it personnally how you treat them... I've been a follower for 30 years and it amazes me how many Pastors & leaders treat most people as if they were born again yesterday. They think they own God and are the only ones who can ever hear His voice or understand His word... Seminary training (or should I say cemetary) makes people arrogant... My life is my seminary training, my personal encounters w/ Christ everyday in every circumstance is what prepares me for HIS ministry IN ME! Leadership doesn't like people who think for themselves and question authority... instead of them building people up they sadly misuse the people to bolster their own egos. They really are wolves in sheeps clothing who devour whole flocks to satisfy their ungodly appetites. Right now the only fellowship I have is over the phone w/ 2 friends from out of state...and I have a very dear friend who is a transgendered (M to F) atheist who has shown me more kindness, love & respect than most Christians! When my car broke down she not only paid for the repairs (transmission), she stopped by my home almost everyday to check on me and see if my family needed anything! Talk about using the the things that are not to nullify the things that are! I live w/ my 19 y/o daughter & 2 y/o grandaughter ... I told her that looking after widows and orphans in their distress was religion God approves of and she seemed stunned by that... I often think that for the church to survive it needs to stop erecting piles of brick to worship and promote... we should meet in each others homes or @ parks... don't many public schools allow for people to use their facilities? Christianity often does not seek to build people up... it wants control over them... they are power hungry . I know there must be some good churches out there, but I haven't been to them... and everytime I start going to a church it's only a matter of time before I piss off their leadership, because I refuse to check my brain at the door and I WILL stand up to B.S.! I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ... I believe the Bible & I love Jesus! He is precious to me... and nobody has any right to dictate to me how to have a personnal relationship w/Him.

Reply
Victor Jones
07/14/2012 17:30

Phylis, "taking care of orphans and widows" is not just "worship that God approves of," it is an essential component of worshipping that God requires to restore a community back to pleasing God. See Isaiah 1.

I came to realization that if i wanted to know Jesus I needed to under stand what God's Word meant to the original writers and audience. Since then i've been led to read Obery Hendricks Jr books and evaluating all messages by God's Word. I realized that I had been taught to fit my understanding of the Bible to fit the preacher's message. he status quo was to

Reply
Daniel
07/12/2012 01:30

What saddens me about the article and the comments is how so many seem to be giving up on our identity. If we are trying to follow Christ then we need to claim the name Christian for ourselves and try and define it on our terms. When we give up, when we don't claim it, when we allow it to stand for bigotry and hatred without offering another vision then we lose the right to complain that people see us as those negatives. We must proclaim not only Christ, but that WE are Christians, not just those who hate, and offer our spirituality to those who are seeking but turned off by the stridency many churches show. To not do so is to hide our light under a bushel basket, and the Lord had something to say about that. This is obviously only a suggestion, but it's something I've tried to intentionally practice since starting seminary. Maybe for the rest of your sabbatical you could balance not going to church with being more intentional in claiming your Christianity, and not allowing that title you rightfully have to be wrested away from you. It may not be the most relaxing thing, but it would hopefully be rejuvenating!!

Reply
Beth Sheppard
07/12/2012 10:57

Why worry about it? We need God, his indwelling presence, and we reach him through Following Jesus .. His way, his truth, his life. I find it easier through the Eucharist, but whatever works.

Reply
Daniel
07/12/2012 19:07

Im worried because labels matter. If we give up calling ourselves Christians, it will make it much much harder to teach people the actual good news of Christ. I also find that I get spiritually fed through the Eucharist, but eucharistians isn't going to get people to the good news nearl as effectively as proudly reclaiming our status-quo-challenging heritage. .

Carol
07/12/2012 03:20

Im glad to read that so many Christians are kind, accepting, non hating people. I wish good Christians would speak up more. Non Christians like me only hear the hateful, nasty, politically frightening Right wing Christians. From my perspective, some Christians seem much more interested in pushing a political agenda ( Theocracy) than following Jesus.

Reply
Daniel
07/12/2012 16:41

Amen! This is what I was saying above. I'm glad you're seeing that there are many Christians out there who aren't motivated by theocratic or right wing agendas. In fact, many of us are involved in progressive or social justice work precisely because of our Christian faith! My hope is that through folks like that people will begin to see that Christian doesn't automatically mean right wing and theocratic.

Reply
WESLEY FITTS SR
07/12/2012 12:45

What You are describing is an performance baisd experience,
This is because they relate to God on the basis of their performance rather than trusting in His grace.
Performance-oriented believers tend to be sin-conscious. For them, Christianity is all about doing good while avoiding sin. Indeed, Romans 7 does talk a lot about sin, but probably not in the way that you think. The word “sin” and its derivatives appears 49 times in Romans. On 47 of these occasions Paul refers to sin as a noun (e.g., sin nature, old self). Only twice does Paul talk about sin as a verb. In other words, Paul is far more interested in nature than behavior. It’s not so much about what you do but who you are.
Grace – The Power of the Gospel will change the way you think. It will liberate you from the curse of dead works and the performance mentality that still binds many in the church

Reply
Nicole
07/12/2012 18:16

I'm so glad I'm not the only one who feels this way!! I strongly dislike calling myself a "Christian" anymore. I was raised in a lesbian household, and regardless of anyone else's views on homosexuality, no one should tell me I can't be a "Christian" and believe in marriage equality. Well why not!!?? My relationship with Christ is no one else's business but my own? How dare anyone tell me to turn my back on a cause that directly affects my life and my family, in order to love Jesus? Who does that!?

Reply
DP
07/14/2012 12:14

just left a call because of many of the same disappointments and amid anonymous complaints of such petty stuff in the midst of live and death situations.

still pondering what i'm even trained for or how i can fit into the real world now.

Reply
Isabel Carr Smart
07/15/2012 07:05

DP: "God says, I will lead you into the wilderness and speak to your heart..." (From Iona Community liturgy) He has done this to me. I am not clergy but was called to serve then rejected by my Minister. I believe God is calling many people out of the Church so that we can begin to be "church" in the wider world and find new ways of being relevant. It takes time to wander in the wilderness and hear the call/find direction after the pain of loss, leaving and grieving; however nothing you are or have learned will be lost when you eventually grow into a new way of being that will benefit a new community, who are longing for a new way of life.

Reply
DP
07/15/2012 16:53

thank you.

Homey Chingaso
07/18/2012 11:57

I left the church when I was a teenager for many of the reasons posted above. I came back to Christianity about 10 years ago, and found a completely different experience. I quickly realized that my problems with Christianity weren't with the Gospel, my problems had been with Christians.

Jesus was anti-religion, and spoke strongly about this. When I explain this to my secular friends and family, they have no idea what I'm talking about. In fact, they think my Christianity is the stereotyped and stigmatized version I used to reject. I'm the prodigal son for sure, and what I found in my return to the Gospel literally changed my life, and it's frustrating that I cannot seem to get people to see past the stigma and stereotype.

Angry Christian and Judgemental Christian should be oxymorons, yet sadly they are how the secular world sees us, and for good reason. Too many self-described Christians tend to cherry-pick scripture to support their worldview, and use the Word to condemn or control people; quite completely using God's word in vain.

I completely unerstand Pastor Sandlin's sabbatical; the modern-day church isn't serving the body as the Church Christ speaks of was intended. He never intended for His teaching to become an organized religion, but instead a way of life, a relationship with Him and our Father; a life lived within and because of this Relationship.

As Christians, second to loving God, our charge is to love our neighbor. Period. It can easily be fact that if one isn't living his or her life based on love, it would be incorrect for them to define themselves as followers of Christ (Christian). So the angry and judgemental among us need to seriously examine how they've allowed their ideology to usurp their relationship with God. How they reconcile their anger and ugliness with their spirituality is beyond me, but at the end of the day, I'm not the one they need to explain it to.

Reply
Tonya
12/20/2012 14:43

I would never deny th oportunity to proclaim that I am a "Christian" whcih just simply means to be Christ like for I feel that in doing so I am denying Christ and what a travesty. We were already informed through the word of God that these days were coming. It doesn't matter what others are doing what matter is the way I chose to respond to what there doing . I am instructed to "let my light shine that man may see my good works and glorify my father which is in heaven. And furthermore I am giving the charge to pray for my bretheren. "If a brother be taken in a fault, ye which are spritual restore them in a spirit of meekness. The wheat in the tare will grow together and God will do the seperating. You are not responsible for the actions of others only for yourself. WE were told to not forsake the assembling of ourselves. You don't know who may be watching your life. I just think we have to be very careful that walk in obedience to Gods word and were in His word do you ever see that he left the church for any reason? He said to the Father if its possible for this cup to pass, but not my will but your well. The Body has need of the true believers to stand up an take authority over all this counterfeit spirits. So admonish each of you to take back the authority given to you through the power of the HOLY GHOST don't you dare leave your position pray that those spirits that are not of God will go and that the true church would come forth in Jesus name. AMEN!!!!!!!!!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply