Change, trust, faith, death of the church, hypocritical, church, burning
The Church is burning down. It is a slow, smoldering burn to be sure, but it is burning down nonetheless. As it burns, those who belong have busied themselves painting over the soot stained walls, putting a new finish over the already depleted structure, in hopes that they will somehow protect the outdated construction that has strayed so far from the Architect's plan.

As the average attendance and membership of mainline protestant churches continue to slowly spiral down, we try to repaint the walls with new contemporary murals, dress up the sanctuary with artistic liturgical dressings and blast out slightly more modern music during the anthem and offertory. The hierarchical structure of the Church (both formal and informal) that sets up power dynamics which are antithetical to the teachings of Jesus? We leave them  alone. The programs, groups and events of the church (from Sunday School to various long established women's or men's groups) that have been struggling, in some cases, for decades? We don't dare change them. The hypocritical judgment of anyone who isn't either one of us or like us? We simply ignore the log in our own eye. 

We, those who have been part of the leadership of the Church, have been redecorating rather than putting out the fire. As we have done so, we have been fanning the flame. We should have been putting an end to the smoldering mess it has become and began renovating, restructuring and repurposing. We should be revisioning our future but instead we are busy decoupaging our church photo albums, not only remembering the “good old days” but insisting that we recreate the still lives we have created in our heads as way to fix the here and now.

The worst part is, we are so frightened of a new future (and the change needed to achieve it) that we continue to repeat this behavior over and over again receiving the same results every time (which is to say, receiving little to no results) and somehow, each time, we think that this time it will be different. We completely fail to realize that our system is perfectly designed to achieve the results we have – a slowly dying church. Burn baby, burn.

The good news is that no matter what happens, the Church will live. We can let it burn all the way down to the ground as we stand by watching while we embrace the memories in our photo album and the Church will go on – just without us.  

It turns out that the God of the Hebrews is prone to doing “a new thing.” God doesn't even flinch at the mention of death. As we learn in the New Testament, God is all about life in spite of death.

We can all choose to play it safe, hold on to what we know, repeat our behavior and our results while we dress them up in a fresh coat of paint, but what the church needs now is a renovating, restructuring and repurposing. We need to get back to the earliest blueprints and be willing to tear out anything that isn't expressly designed by the original Architect. We have to stop measuring the new design with yardsticks of our comfort and start measuring them with tape measures delineated with markings of love, grace, forgiveness and acceptance.

It will take real faith, so I doubt many church will, as Dr. King put it, take the first step without seeing the whole staircase.

But the Church is burning down, smoldering in its own self-focused care, fearfully protecting the very internal structures that it is allowing to burn down by protecting them. Ironic, isn't it? Worse yet, somewhere deep inside, we think we are protecting ourselves and those who've gathered around us in the Church, but we are actually hurting ourselves and them. We are not only denying our need for real faith, but we are denying our opportunity to live into the Great Commission as we continually support and defend systems and practices that have proven what results we should expect of them and have caused those on the outside to look at us and rightful call us hypocritical. 

The Church is burning down. It is time for real faith. It is time for real change. It is time to trust the Architect. If we don't the Church will die. It will rise again, but without us. I, for one, want to be a part of the body of Christ rather than apart from it. I am willing to put my trust in God and to step out on faith, no matter what that means Church looks like, no matter what systems, hierarchies, programs, groups and events must be sacrificed at the alter. Are you?

 


Comments

Hope
06/14/2011 15:35

It is happening whether we are on board or not

Reply
Chris Johnson
06/14/2011 15:38

I'm seeing this happen almost literally in the small church I serve part-time. I've been trying for years to get them to do some kind of evangelism and outreach, and they just won't. They've spent many 10s of thousands of dollars on the church interior, but won't put a sign by the road indicating when they worship, and won't modify the service or music. They've decided to die, though they can't actually admit that. It's so frustrating.

Reply
Roger Smith
06/14/2011 16:41

I'm looking forward to "Extreme Makeover: Church Edition", where they tear down a tottering, filthy wreck and build something beautiful that really is more of a home.

Reply
Ben
06/14/2011 17:02

I love the last paragraph the most.

Reply
Don Rappe
06/14/2011 17:09

An excellent and well thought out article.

Reply
06/15/2011 07:38

At its best, the Church should always be in a state of dying to itself so that Christ might live. If we take our faith seriously, we are called to sacrifice even our beloved artifice and sacred cows so that the world may know Christ.

Fr. Daniel Berrigan was a radical, activist, social justice oriented, Catholic priest. He rarely wore the standard black clerical garb with white collar. Instead, he typically wore blue jeans and a denim work shirt. When asked why he did this, he replied, "If you want to follow Jesus, you need to look good... ...on wood."

Here's to trading our churchy duds for some down to earth clothing that's better suited for roasting marshmallows at a bonfire.

And the Church like a firebird, always rises.

I've dedicated my book "Kissing Fish: christainity for people who don't like christianity," to this essential conviction; i.e., for the world and the Christianity that my son and his generation will inherit.

Thank you for this blog.

Reply
Mike B
06/15/2011 13:59

Excellent article, and I agree wholeheartedly. The metaphor of "redecorating while the house is on fire" is superbly well represented IMHO, and it's accurate for sure.

I would recommend reading anything by Frank Viola, especially "Pagan Christianity" and it's 2 follow ups.

Reply
Dorothy
03/18/2012 08:19

Thank you for articulating what I have been seeing in the small congregation I used to be a part of. The vision of progressive leaders across denominations is what gives me hope for the Kingdom!

Reply
Andrea Schafer
03/18/2012 08:48

Totally agree..........but help! Give me some ideas! What can we do to put out the fire? (and kindle a NEW one?)

Reply
Annie
03/18/2012 08:52

WOW! Excellent piece! You have put into words what my husband, a former Methodist local licensed pastor,and I have been thinking for several years. I will be sure to have him read this.THANK YOU!

Reply
Kelly Cowan
03/18/2012 09:02

The Church is the Holy Spirit, not some man made building or institution. The church (lower case c) is the result of Emperor Constantine's Edict of Milan in 313 A.D., and as such has nothing to do with the Church. When the Roman Empire legalized christianity (lower case c), they also usurped it, and began to use it as a political and business tool for global conquest and imperialism. Throughout history the name of Jesus has been used to commit genocide, start wars, plunder resources, rape, murder, and every manner of evil one can imagine. The true message of Christ is diametrically opposite to what passes for christianity in most of the numerous, conflicting denominations of christianity today. Christianity is in The Spirit, and can not be burned down, while christianity was designed to be destroyed.

Reply
03/18/2012 09:17

This quote from Dorothy Day is what helps me to understand what a Christian's relationship to The Church should be:

"I loved the Church for Christ made visible. Not for itself, because it was so often a scandal to me. Romano Guardini said the Church is the Cross on which Christ as crucified; one could not separate Christ from His Cross, and one must live in a state of permanent dissatisfaction with the Church."

It's in the Long Loneliness, page 252, I believe.

Reply
03/18/2012 09:23

Let it burn. When the last vestiges of The (fill in the blank) Church are gone, believers can gather again in their homes, and in gardens and in parks and support one another ... NOT support a political bureaucracy.
WHY do you need someone to tell you what to believe? Especially if that person has been sent to a training facility to teach you you to believe what someone else taught him to believe...
Beliefs are either yours that you develop and discover or they are someone else's that you are just parroting.
LET IT BURN.

Reply
MuleChewingBriars
03/18/2012 10:03

"There is no way to defeat the Cross. The Cross itself is Defeat." GK Chesterton

"There is nothing in this world as contemptuous, as easy to despise, as Orthodox Ecclesiology. Since it depends on mutual love and submission between the bishops, clergy, and laity of the Church, it can be strong enough to withstand the greatest hammer blows or too weak to support an argument over who gets the last serving of fried eggplant." Alexander Schmemann

Reply
03/18/2012 10:27

As a former evangelical Christian, I applaud the burning of the Church. Like any infested field, the only purge is fire. We've tried insecticides (Protestantism) and antiseptics (cults like Mormon and JW) but nothing will work, other than fire. If it burns to the ground, so much better. As far as The Plan? Nothing is ever outside The Plan. This is as much a part of it as Saturn's rings and black holes. Nothing thwarts Source. Ever. To think humans could do such a thing is the height of arrogance.

Reply
Brandon
03/20/2012 23:26

"We've tried insecticides (Protestantism) and antiseptics (cults like Mormon and JW) but nothing will work, other than fire."
Isn't this attitude exactly the antithesis of that which the author of this article is recommending? Calling Mormons and Jehovah's Witnesses cults and bashing religions other than your own is a huge reason that the church is falling apart. I was raised Lutheran, baptized Mormon and I believe Christ is my savior. I know I don't have all the answers but I know you don't either and I think you are right to think that the height of arrogance is to think humans could solve this problem. Take your own advice, you don't know the whole Truth and therefore have no right to bash the version of it that I have found in my relationship with Christ.

Reply
Jim N
03/18/2012 11:08

Get back to preaching a personal relationship with Christ! Our church is growing by leaps and bounds. We have 2, sometimes 3 or 4 services on two campuses with around 8000 in attendance each Sunday.

Reply
Mark
03/18/2012 12:47

That 's one reality show I will tune in for.

Reply
Kyle
03/18/2012 19:46

It's a good article, here's a couple of practical suggestions-

1.) The church needs to STOP being the place where non-christians go to hear the gospel. In the ancient church for centuries, christians would go out into the world, evangelize the lost, those people would become christians & then they would be brought into the church. But with the format we've had for a long time, you end up having more non-christians than christians in the church. The church should be a place where believers can be encouraged & edified, I.E. Strengthened in the Word. Another problem with this format is that it keeps the sermons at a 'Milk' level of depth, because so much time is spent preaching the gospel to those who should already know it. The people in church should already be ready for 'Meat' preaching & they aren't getting it.

2.) We need to be more discerning about Wolves in the flock. It was one of the most earnest things Paul preached about, but in our culture we are way too focused on being 'nice', 'accepting' and 'non-judgemental'. This has allowed wolves to ravage the sheep. I know of a pastor who has spent decades working with the police & he has hard evidence that our enemies (Satanists, they exist, deny it at your own risk), will actually go into a community, specifically target Holy-Spirit-filled churches, and then work on infiltrating & wreaking them. Now who in any church you know even looks out for this tactic? But it is done all over the country.

Reply
Edward
03/18/2012 21:06

That was a article but I did not see one scripture in there to back it up. This is just another human thought.
The church is burning down for lack of scripture in the lives of sinners.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply